Friday, May 04, 2007

Iraq: A teenage girl was stoned to death for loving the wrong boy

(Daily Mail) A 17-year-old girl has been stoned to death in Iraq because she loved a teenage boy of the wrong religion.

As a horrifying video of the stoning went out on the Internet, the British arm of Amnesty International condemned the death of Du’a Khalil Aswad as "an abhorrent murder" and demanded that her killers be brought to justice.

Reports from Iraq said a local security force witnessed the incident, but did nothing to try to stop it. Now her boyfriend is in hiding in fear for his life.

Miss Aswad, a member of a minority Kurdish religious group called Yezidi, was condemned to death as an "honour killing" by other men in her family and hardline religious leaders because of her relationship with the Sunni Muslim boy.

They said she had shamed herself and her family when she failed to return home one night. Some reports suggested she had converted to Islam to be closer to her boyfriend.

Miss Aswad had taken shelter in the house of a Yezidi tribal leader in Bashika, a predominantly Kurdish town near the northern capital, Mosul.

A large crowd watched as eight or nine men stormed the house and dragged Miss Aswad into the street. There they hurled stones at her for half an hour until she was dead.



The stoning happened last month, but only came to light yesterday with the release of the Internet video.

It is feared her death has already triggered a retaliatory attack. Last week 23 Yezidi workmen were forced off a bus travelling from Mosulto Bashika by a group of Sunni gunmen and summarily shot dead.

An Amnesty International spokesman in London said they receive frequent reports of honour crimes from Iraq – particularly in the predominantly Kurdish north.

Most victims are women and girls who are considered by male relatives to have shamed their families by immoral behaviour.

Kurdish authorities have introduced reforms outlawing honour killings, but have failed to investigate them or prosecute suspects, added the Amnesty spokesman.

Kate Allen, the organisation’s UK director, said: "This young girl’s murder is truly abhorrent and her killers must be brought to justice.

"Unless the authorities respond vigorously to this and any other reports of crimes in the name of 'honour', we must fear for the future of women in Iraq."

35 comments:

Anonymous said...

Savages...

Anonymous said...

Exterminate them all. They have forfeit their right to exist.

Anonymous said...

She probably shouldn't have been such a slut. Honestly, if the law is "sleep with that guy and die" and you sleep with that guy, then you probably know what's coming.

Anonymous said...

I agree that if she knew what she was getting herself into...

But it's still inhumane. If it was absolutely neccessary to kill her, shoot her in the head, don't spend half an hour throwing rocks at her.

Anonymous said...

Two the two posters above me, are you fucking kidding me?

Anonymous said...

just another reason why religion is such bullshit.

wake up people! When you die thats it! there is no entity waiting for you on the otherside.

People created god. god didn't create people

Anonymous said...

fuck them, how do you not see this as being wrong. id personialy like to stone those shitheads and piss on their bloddy faces.

Anonymous said...

"Anonymous said...

She probably shouldn't have been such a slut. Honestly, if the law is "sleep with that guy and die" and you sleep with that guy, then you probably know what's coming."

You have GOT to be fucking kidding me. FUNDIE ALERT

Religion has the best trolls.

Anonymous said...

The apologists above are just being conservative; if it's against the law it must be morally wrong. Things must always be simple.

That's idiotic, of course. No matter how foolish her behavior was, or illegal, it was definitely not morally wrong to fall for a guy of a different religion.

That means she should not have been punished. The law is unjust, see? Oh, never mind.

Anonymous said...

The video is no longer working. Any other links? The world should see it, so they can wake the hell up about these idiots.

Anonymous said...

Miss Aswad

HAHAHAHA

Anonymous said...

MISS ASSWAD!!! hahahahah

Portugal said...

hum.. isto é uma barbaridade!
Espancar uma rapariga de 17 anos por gostar de outra pessoa ? pobre da menina :( .
para todas as pessoas que fizeram isso deviam ser amaldiçoadas pelo que fizeram... é apenas uma rapariga com sentimentos por um rapaz.

Anonymous said...

Fuck Islam, Fuck Christianity, Fuck Hinduism...basically FUCK all religions! It is the biggest load of shit ever. I have always believed this since I was 6 (I am 31 now.) Brainless sheep follow them, use your brain for once and 'think' about how things really are all you religious zealots. Have a nice day. :)

Anonymous said...

To the above poster who is so interested in having sex with various religions...and has wanted to do that since he was 6 years old...

Do you actually kiss your pet goat with that mouth?! I'm really surprised you two would even have a relationship after that 'brainless' rant.

A girl is stoned to death in Iraq, so lets unload on every religion on earth, that'll fix things!

I always get a kick out of people who deny the existence of a God, it's usually either because things didn't go their way earlier in life (God's fault), or so they can justify their own bestial behaviours...kind of makes you feel sorry for the goat!

Anonymous said...

Why do you post a video (or embed a link to it, there's no difference in the achieved effect) of somebody being stoned, then?

It's sadistic voyeurism like this that rewards extremist behaviour by giving them and the people recording these atrocities the attention they desire. (No, I didn't watch the video past the first ten seconds, but it's pretty safe to assume that this was the content of the movie.)
Moreover, these sensationalist posts are great too attract masses of readers chasing from one 'scandal' to the next (it's no coincidence that I was given this link by a friend, after all). Sure, it's important to highlight and eradicate the evil on this world, yadda yadda, but especially the showing of such movies is usually a sure sign that encouraging meaningful discussions are not the primary goal of a website/article. And I'm really fed up of all this bullshit; it serves *nothing* to make the world a better place (horrible things happen *every day* on the world, and I definitely don't think that the constant media attention given to beheadings, torture, and similar atrocities do anything to make the world a nicer, safer place for any party. Just look at many of the comments to see the responses they provoke (I find this particularly ironic given that the death penalty is legal in the US, but that's just me)).
< / rant>

Tom said...

This is without a doubt one of the most abhorrent things I have ever witnessed. I mean... it's one thing to have the capabilities as a human to kill a young female in such a brutal way, and another to film it for some sort of personal pleasure.

I don't consider myself a racist person at all.. but when you see shit like this, it's hard not to want to see people who practise this faith die in horrible ways.

The wars waged on the middle east by america were unjust, but if they wipe out animals like this I'm changing my stance to pro.

Anonymous said...

EVERY mother fucking muslim PIG should be wiped away from the face of the Earth!!! You do not deserve to live and breath the same air as me and my people if you can do something like this to another human being. GOD is not happy is you shit for brains. You will all lead us to a nuclear end of the world. Stop you fucking bullshit religion, you are degenarates, you do not deserve to live. Come close to me or my familly, and it's open season on ragheads...

Anonymous said...

In response to the post above this one: that long-winded Muslim bashing comment of yours is just a testament to your small-minded mentality. There's nothing Muslim about this particular 'honor killing.' Nor is it linked to any Muslims as it cites followers of the Yazidi religion. Try and pay attention to the snippet, dig?

Regardless, this is one of the worst instances of abuse coming from the country today, coupled with the ongoing war in Iraq, it's hard to see any positive outcomes. I do hope those responsible are brought to swift justice. I nearly cried upon seeing this...ugh, talk about depression...

Anonymous said...

They are nothing more than animals, although I would not waste the money on a humane killing.

Sounds like a good test ground for the effects of a nuclear weapon.

This kind of savagery cannot be allowed to spread the the civilized world.

Anonymous said...

such a terrible shame. In reply to:
Anonymous said...
fuck them, how do you not see this as being wrong. id personialy like to stone those shitheads and piss on their bloddy faces.Friday, May 04, 2007 5:23:00 PM I would like to say that is exactly how I feel about Bush and Ca-Chin Cheney - Yup, stone the bastards and piss in their bloody faces right before they take their last breath.

Anonymous said...

Exterminate them all. They have forfeit their right to exist.
STFU, You're an idiot.

She probably shouldn't have been such a slut. Honestly, if the law is "sleep with that guy and die" and you sleep with that guy, then you probably know what's coming.
STFU, You're an idiot.

I agree that if she knew what she was getting herself into...
But it's still inhumane. If it was absolutely neccessary to kill her, shoot her in the head, don't spend half an hour throwing rocks at her.

STFU, You're an idiot.

just another reason why religion is such bullshit.
wake up people! When you die thats it! there is no entity waiting for you on the otherside.
People created god. god didn't create people

STFU, You're an idiot.

Miss Aswad
HAHAHAHA

STFU, You're an idiot.

Fuck Islam, Fuck Christianity, Fuck Hinduism...basically FUCK all religions! It is the biggest load of shit ever. I have always believed this since I was 6 (I am 31 now.) Brainless sheep follow them, use your brain for once and 'think' about how things really are all you religious zealots. Have a nice day. :)
STFU, You're an idiot.

EVERY mother fucking muslim PIG should be wiped away from the face of the Earth!!! You do not deserve to live and breath the same air as me and my people if you can do something like this to another human being. GOD is not happy is you shit for brains. You will all lead us to a nuclear end of the world. Stop you fucking bullshit religion, you are degenarates, you do not deserve to live. Come close to me or my familly, and it's open season on ragheads...
STFU, You're an idiot.

They are nothing more than animals, although I would not waste the money on a humane killing.
Sounds like a good test ground for the effects of a nuclear weapon.
This kind of savagery cannot be allowed to spread the the civilized world.

STFU, You're an idiot.

odayict said...

I am an Arab Muslim, and I tell you this brutality is fuckin cultural nothing to do with Islam.

Leaving aside who we fellow or anything...this goes against humanity PERIOD

This is the very Arab savegry Islam wanted to remove..the ARABS USE TO BURRY THEIR DAUGTHERS ALIVE until Islam came...but still the honour killings do exist and its disgusting.

Anonymous said...

DEATH THE ISLAM!!! BASTARDS! MURDER! I PISS OF ALL MUSLEMS!

Anonymous said...

With all due respect to the people claiming "f all religion" you live because of Christianity, and nothing but. Atheism murdered over 300 million people in the 20th century, and only Christianity ended slavery and mass murder around the world to the extent it has been stopped. The weakening of Christian nations by moral compromise is why the Islamics and collectivists have been getting away with murder again in recent decades.

Anonymous said...

Is it is wrong to take a life in the name of peace? Any more so than in the name of honor? If you see a distinction you've not gripped the stock of the sword.
Nothing is more mindless than a crowd of people who feel it their civic duty to dispense justice in a tradition that goes back for thousands of years. And for those of you aghast at the sight of this video- did you stumble on this web page or did you seek it out? There is in all of us a taste for blood. We want to understand her death in European terms, modern terms that unfortunately, cannot be applied to her situation; a deep societal precedence lays claim to an Arab's notion of justice. Because this justice is prescribed so violently does not make it morally reprehensible. Only within the context of a societies norms can one judge something as moral or immoral. And lest we forget, self righteous Americans, lynching was a perfectly acceptable form of justice only 80 years ago. Drawing and Quartering of a man or woman was an acceptable form only 120 years ago. And god have mercy on the nonwhites found guilty of crimes in France, England and the U.S. prior to 1950. By our standards today, any countries dispensation of jurisprudence twenty years ago would seem coarse and inhumane.
The point of this rant?
Bring the dark culture of yesterday into the light of today by caring about the people there. All of them. Even those who would throw the first stone. Show them what modernization can do. And love them as your heart would want to be loved, without a savior or religious agenda to support you. But call them animals, blame their religion, wish for their death, and immediately you ostracize them from the good you would hope to impart; your hatred and lack of understanding only breeds in them further separatism and inflexibility. Do not forget how easy it is to define ourselves by who are opponents are. Take away the desire to defeat, and all that you have left is the fear of being defeated. What does this say about our course of action in the middle east? Replace the desire to defeat with the desire to love and what is there to be afraid of? Being loved to death? I know this sounds like a tree hugging fantasy, but where would true world peace begin then?
You tell me.

Anonymous said...

To " Anonymous said...

DEATH THE ISLAM!!! BASTARDS! MURDER! I PISS OF ALL MUSLEMS!/"

Ok clearly the article said she WAS NOT Muslim, she converted to Islam and was STONED BECAUSE she CONVERTED TO ISLAM and MARRIED/LIKED a Muslim boy. The PEOPLE who STONED her were NOT Muslim they WERE YEZIDI. Obviously you guys need to learn how to read.

And to everyone who is making comments against religion, there is nothing in religion that supports this kind of behavior it is ALL CULTURAL. Culture is the very corrupting force, well at least arab/persian/pakistani culture that is so ridiculously backwards, that allows these things to happen. If you find a true intellectual person and not some idiot religious leader from the third world who doesn't know shiznet, you'll find that religion is actually peaceful. Seriously it's like saying


And to the person who said she was a slut and deserved this ARE YOU EVEN HUMAN?! She could be a whore and she STILL WOULD NOT DESERVE THIS. NO ONE deserves this. It doesn't matter what you're moral standards are, your religion, gender, sexual preference, etc. Nobody deserves to be treated or die this way, NO ONE. If you think religion tolerates this kind of abuse then you need to go an re-read the books about God's love for humanity and his people. Yes he may not tolerate certain actions but He doesn't tell us to treat his people this way.

Anonymous said...

WOAH I just realized this site is ridiculously anti-Islam. Buddy who made this site have you actually done your full research that made you put up these ridiculous advertisements? I see the Israeli flag...hmm i wonder?

oh and that supposed Palestinian celebration after 9/11 was not after 9/11 but footage from a something else. Its a known fact. And to let you know being this biased gives you NO political validity or reliability people just see you as a hardcore, biased zionist.

(by the way I'm the person that posted the above comment)


oh and the road to truth? you're so biased that you couldn't be further from the truth you LIAR

Anonymous said...

Eye On The World

The road to truth is long, and lined the entire way with annoying bastards.


...yea like yourself you stupid zionist


the video is really sad though, i'm going to do more research about it to see if its true or another dumb jewish conspiracy against arabs.

Anonymous said...

so,, humanity is cruel. people have done HORRIBEL things to another, in wars etc. There HAS been more awful things humans have done. I live in europe.. we burned "witches" some 100 years ago.. can you compare burning witches to this? I don't know. but if you saw a video-clip when burning a person, you WOULD feel sick to your stomache too!!! CAN you compare it? let me think. hmm, maybe stoning this girl was a little bit more inhumane. she had to suffer for a long time, and she didn't get a trial. but as a german guy said to me: you can't compare evil, that's absurd! so calling these who did this thing animals are correct. but it wasn't so long ago we burned "witches". tobias_joha@hotmail.com

Anonymous said...

While this is arguably the most gruesome thing I have ever witnessed in my life, there are a few points that should be raised for the benefit of most of the "groups" who are represented in these posts.

It is not the story that has everyone hammering away with responses in the negative or otherwise. It is the graphic, in your face, one of the crowd footage, despite it's poor picture quality. Every day for as long as I can remember (I'm 41), some one, some where in the world died as a result of massive head trauma, caused invariably by large chunks of rock, bricks, concrete and all manner of other debris/shrapnel, caused by US$250K rockets, dropped from multi-million dollar "stealth" bombers or other equally impressive flying machines built solely for the purpose of delivering death and destruction.

To reflect upon the tragic and by most people's standards grossly inhumane "murder" of Du’a Khalil Aswad (noting that I'm the first person commenting here, to actually refer to her by her name - another of the things that helps us identify with her - because the victim in this case has a name),I think it is important to note the following.
1 Du'a could see the faces of her attackers for the most part. They werent in the sky.
2 Despite how wrong we feel it is, Du'a at least had an idea of WHY they did it. Unlike the millions of innocent victims of war.

Perhaps if the countries who send soldiers to fight wars were made to record the scenes of the innocent victims - say for instance a family of 8 or so people in the lounge room when the building is hit by a bomb or missile - and post them all on YouTube, then we'd all (people from around the world) show the same outrage as we can muster for poor Du'a and the soldiers wouldn't be sent so frivolously.

The final point I'll make is this. We have been ganging up and murdering each other for one reason or another throughout history. Until the world has the same same laws and standards of human decency throughout, there will always be fighting on earth. No war will bring that about. Only time will. Religion will die out on its own as humanity comes to terms with the true science of human evolution and we'll go to war united against other worlds, because there has to be an enemy. For the poor humans in this video, their only fault was to have had the misfortune to be born and grow up in a place where it is still considered not only acceptable but probably thier duty to behave this way. How does that compare to a child who was fortunate enough to be born and raised in the west, with stable government, law and order, health and education, food and water and opportunities galore, who upon adulthood, and despite growing up "civilised", joins the army and goes to a country who's language you can't speak, and drop bombs on innocent people.

There's bad people everywhere, and some of them aren't muslims, or christians or jews or hindus or buddhist or anything else.

Have children and teach them to be tolerant. If we all do that for a dozen or so generations, maybe, just maybe there'll be no more unnatural deaths - no more innocent victims of others. Maybe.

Anonymous said...

THE EVIL THAT MAN DO

Anonymous said...

Nuclear bombs + middle east = world peace

that is all.

Anonymous said...

This is disturbing. It was a community rape and murder of a girl. These people are animals in the eyes of God and will suffer his retribution and his wrath.

zimbie said...

malditos deberian morir todos los q estaban ahi y no hicieron nada todos deberian morir asi quien dice q esta prohibido enamorarse malditos ojalas todos los q hayan estado ahi y no hayan hecho nada les pase lo mismo por mal nacidos!!!